BillPentz.com :: Dust Collection Research :: Home

Home

Table of Contents

(click on topic to go there)
  1. Foreword
  2. Summary
  3. Applicability
  4. Acknowledgements
  5. Financial Help
  6. Navigation
UNDER CONSTRUCTION

Please be patient as these pages continue to get rewritten. If you find problem areas or confusion, please let me know via email at BPentz@cnets.net

  1. Foreword
  2. Most small shop workers wrongly think that fine wood dust poses little risk because we put limited time in our shops and use dust collection equipment with fine filters that leave us with clean looking shops. I learned the hard way that my clean looking shop provided a bad false sense of security. I landed in the hospital with an apparent heart attack from fine wood dust that shut down my respiratory system leaving my heart with inusfficient oxygen. A few different things contributed to my problem. Fine wood dust reduced my respiratory capacity after a lifetime or woodworking. I vented my cyclone dust collector inside. Its filter freely passed the fine invisible dust that causes the most harm to our health. I made things worse by working fairly toxic woods. Almost any activity launched this fine dust airborne. This left me blindsided from a clean looking shop that tested with dangerously high amounts of airborne wood dust. My continued heavy exposure to this dust developed a bad sensitivity meaning strong allergic reaction. I argued strongly that I already had good fine dust collection. I used the “top” rated dust collection system with the “best” rated small shop cyclone including vendor designed and supplied ducting and even vendor recommended fine filter upgrade. After reminding me that I was in the hospital with allergy testing that proved with nasty welts and boils I had a big problem with wood dust, he convinced me to spend my recovery time doing research on what went wrong and what I needed to do to make repair. A little study on the dangers of fine dust convinced me to get costly air quality testing on my home and shop. That testing showed my big expensive cyclone so badly contaminated my shop and home that I would have been better off just opening a door and using a big fan blowing the air out of my shop. This inspired me to get to work to figure out what was needed to clean up my shop.

    After seeing the changes to my shop and new cyclone design, my respiratory doctor, who is also an avid woodworker, talked me into sharing what I learned about the dangers of fine dust and the many changes I made to control fine dust. I shared that information on some long Internet woodworking forum posts and was immediately buried in emails. In self defense I moved those articles to these Cyclone and Dust Collection Research pages, plus started an active testing program. With help from my friends all over we tested almost every well known brand, size and type of small shop dust collection system. Sharing those results on these pages upset just about everyone. Nobody wanted to hear that their expensive dust collection system worked poorly. Our vendors were even less happy because this testing showed they inflated their airflow claims two to three times and filter claims ten to twenty times what we actually measured from their systems in real use. This testing clearly hosed almost all under 3 hp dust collectors and cyclones less than 3.5 hp moved too little air for good fine dust collection. Worse, most small shop vendors sold “fine” filters that freely passed the finest dust particles which are invisible without magnification right through. With it taking months to years for this fine dust to dissipate, every small shop dust collector and cyclone we tested when vented inside raised the dust levels so high that most small shop workers end up getting more fine dust exposure in a few hours than full time workers in larger facilities that vent outside get in months.

  3. Summary
  4. This site focuses on the fine invisible dust that often escapes collection and is known to cause the most damage to our health. Roughly one pound out of every twenty pounds of sawdust we make is made up of fine dust particles which are invisible without magnification. This dust not only goes right through most small shop dust collector and cyclone filters, it gets right past our bodies’ natural protections where these sharp particles lodge deep in our tissues damaging cells leading to scaring and permanent loss of respiratory capacity. This fine invisible dust is so unhealthy regardless of source that the EPA standard allows no more than 0.15 milligrams per cubic meter of air. Additionally wood dust can contain many toxic chemicals. These chemicals can be poisonous and cause nerve damage, can be strong irritants that lead to chronic infections, can be sensitizers that cause us to build up potentially dangerous allergic reactions, and can increase our risk of cancer, particularly nasal cancers almost only found in those with wood dust exposure. Because of these chemical risks the medical recommendation and European standard only allow a maximum of 0.1 milligrams per cubic meter of air. This means a typical two-car garage sized shop will fail an a medical air quality test as soon as 9 milligrams or 0.00032 ounces of dust is airborne. We get more airborne dust than this when we slap a dusty apron.

    Long ago air engineers worked through the math and physics to provide good fine dust collection then refined their solutions through decades of practical experience. Because smaller tools found in large shops are the same tools we use in our small shops, we can use much of this same information. This site translates this engineering information to share how to setup good fine dust collection in our small shops. This site also shares my plans to make my cyclone design that medical school testing shows provides five times better fine dust collection than its nearest competitor which is my earlier cyclone design. For those who do not have the time or patience to build their own cyclone this site also provides referrals to
    Clear Vue Cyclones who is the only vendor I authorize to make and sell my cyclone design. This site also shares detailed building plans to make your own hoods, blower, muffler, downdraft table, ducting design, air cleaner, and the other components needed for good fine dust collection. It also shares how to test your dust collection airflow and your shop airborne dust levels, plus gives answers to frequently asked questions.

  5. Applicability
  6. This site started off as a project to help woodworkers, but all who are exposed to fine dust are at similar risk. Many ranging from those who work with fiberglass, those who roast coffee, to those who work with grain storage strongly recommend reading these pages. In fact, three of the best known large industrial dust collection providers whose customers must conduct regular air quality testing now make reading this site mandatory for their staff and highly recommend its reading to their customers.

  7. Acknowledgements
  8. These web pages and my designs were not a one person effort and I would have long ago given up without lots of support and the incredible help and feedback from hundreds of people who have helped keep this information accurate and useful. Jim Halbert, Dr. Rod Cole (Ducting Static), and many others provided years of forum posts and articles to get my education rolling. Jim Halbert shared his neutral vane upgrade, portable cyclone design, his automated blast gates, his air measurement pages, his DC remote controller and circuit diagram, and his cyclone vacuum. He also looked over my shoulder for years providing constant feedback to ensure my efforts were accurate and understandable. Others like Don Beale, the air engineer who started the Wood Magazine Dust Collection/Air Filtration forum, iterated for countless hours helping me to get the CFM requirement tables, resistance calculator, hood designs, ducting designs, and many other portions accurate, complete, and also written with diagrams so they were understandable. Don also sent me enough reading material to earn another degree.

    Many of my friends helped me through my cyclone, blower, motor, impeller, tool hoods, ducting, and web page work. My special thanks to Bob Lemon, Dan Moening, Mike Worthan, Dale Critchlow, Glenn Paskaruk, Steve Knight, Steve Cater, Daryl Adams, Richard Winchester, Peter Hunt, Jack Diemer, Rodger Holland, and innumerable other local and Internet friends. Larry Adcock (WoodSucker), Chris O'Connor (AAF), Paul Paton (Sheldon's Engineering), Allan Johanson who now moderates the
    Wood Magazine Dust Collection/Air Filtration forum , Dick and Rick Wynn (Wynn Environmental), Ed and Matt Morgano (Clear Vue Cyclones), Lee Styron (Shark Guard), innumerable Cal-OSHA staff and contractors, plus many commercial dust collection firms helped keep me focused and relevant, provided small shop owners with discounted components, plus showed and shared how to do things right. Many others contributed time, expertise, and even a little money to assist this effort. Terry Hatfield kept me rewriting this information and adding graphics until it became something that most can read and clearly understand. I especially want to thank Steve Hall who took the time to use his expertise as a web designer to totally redesign this site in early 2007 so it is much cleaner and loads far faster. Thanks Steve!

    To each who contributed, I am most thankful and sincerely believe you helped make a big difference, but we still have a long way to go as shown by my recent testing. Our reward is not a pile of gold, but instead knowing that we have helped create a source of accurate information to help woodworkers educate themselves to better protect their health. Our efforts are well heard. Since beginning this effort in 1999, hobbyist vendor filters, cyclones, and dust collectors improved rapidly, plus more “real world” testing helps woodworkers make better decisions. I continue to encourage all to keep up the good work. I think we all deserve a well-earned hand, and my thanks to all who helped and keep helping!

    Bill Pentz

  9. Financial Help
  10. Helping the many who view these pages daily and knowing thousands all over the world use my cyclone design leaves a positive feeling, but does not pay the bills. Since 1999 when I began sharing this work I have spent at least $10,000 every year on these dust collection education efforts. In 2006 my actual expenses on ISP access, licensing, testing, test equipment, and refining the designs I share cost me $15,892.05 out of pocket. With only 14 donations in 2005 and 43 donations generating $492 in 2006 these donations plus a total of $3093.67 from advertisers for 2006 leaves this site not even coming close to covering its cost of operation. I admit this is a labor of love and my choice to keep this work going, but my respiratory problems forced me to retire, so I no longer have the income to keep up this level of sharing. So please, if you find this information useful support these efforts with a check for what you feel this information is worth or at least a small on-line contribution each time you visit these pages.

    You may pay me through
    PayPal to BPentz@cnets.net
    or by sending a check to
    Bill Pentz
    1909 Studebaker Place
    Gold River, CA 95670

  11. Navigation
  12. These web pages regularly get changed and most browsers do not automatically get the most current version unless you do a page refresh, so please refresh each page that you come back to visit. Links to other Internet information are underlined and provided in blue you can click on these links for additional information. Please start by reading over the Introduction then the Dust Collection Basics followed by the Medical Risks and Doctor’s Orders pages.

Click here for: Introduction

Please Support Our Sponsors!